Welp, I guess it’s time to rewrite, huh?
Daniel Jones is gone, released, excised from this bedraggled 2026 Colts squad, and not a moment too soon.
I don’t know who should be more thrilled, Jones himself or desperate and angry Colts fans.
Now whether this was Carlie Irsay-Gordon’s call or Shane Steichen’s call — I’m inclined to believe it’s the former — Jones, the worst statistical starting quarterback in the league, has been given his freedom. And he leaves with lots of cash in his wallet. This is a guy who turned one good season in New York and one 10-game stretch with the Colts into $172 million, so let’s not feel too sorry for Jones (not that you were inclined to feel sorry for him).
And to think, just two weeks ago, the Colts had opportunities to move Jones for some draft capital and decided against it. What, so he could stink it up for a couple more weeks? They should have cleaned house before the trade deadline, moved Jones and Jonathan Taylor, but now they’re getting nothing in exchange for Jones and Taylor’s worth is diminishing with every passing week.
I honestly believed Steichen was closing in on a decision to bench Jones and start Anthony Richardson as soon as next Sunday’s home game against the Giants. A release, most of us did not see coming. Maybe it’s to give Jones a chance to catch on somewhere else. Maybe they’d just seen enough during 11 games of horrific quarterbacking. But was time to turn to Richardson. Finally.
“It’s gonna be great,” Steichen said of the opportunity in front of Richardson. “He’s going to get a full week of practice. Obviously, from his rookie year till now, he’s matured a lot with his preparation and how he goes about it…I’m excited to see him play and go compete, and obviously he brings a unique skill set that’s very athletic and can run around and make some plays. So, looking forward to seeing that.”
Is he? Really?
He’s spent the last few years doing everything short of Super-Glueing Richardson to the bench, and now he’s eager to see what he can do? If this was Steichen’s call, he would have benched Jones and inserted Richardson a long time ago. I won’t bore you with all the stats; you know what you see, and it was patently awful.
Now, in Jones’ defense, he didn’t have much of a chance to succeed this year, starting with the injury to Alec Pierce and continuing with the recent garage sale that saw four starters, three of them offensive players, moved in trades. I can’t imagine Richardson is going to do much better, but you have to ask, how could he do worse?
Guess we’ll find out soon enough.
At least for one week, the Colts will be mildly interesting. And who knows, maybe Richardson, an elite athlete, can give this group a small boost. Clearly, the Colts, from management down to the players, were done with Jones. To Jones’ credit, he played last season with a leg fracture and gutted it out before tearing his Achilles down in Jacksonville. But this follows a pattern: Jones plays great, gets paid, then goes in the tank. That’s not to suggest he stopped working or caring — the guy is a professional — but it’s hard to ignore. The Giants gave him the big bucks and he was never the same again.
Anyway, without further ado, here’s the Dopey Report Card, which has been updated to reflect this afternoon’s seismic news:
RUN OFFENSE
Steichen has the right general idea, leaning into the idea this has to be a run-first offense. But there’s a significant problem with that. With the young and reshuffled line in front of him, there’s absolutely nowhere to go. Jonathan Taylor finished with 21 yards on 11 carries, one of the puniest totals of his brilliant career. At this point, the Colts are de-valuing Taylor, who won’t be able to command a second-rounder and a fifth-rounder when they move him this spring. Makes you wonder why they held onto him. He’s clearly not a part of this grim future. What’s the point of keeping him? Your guess is as good as mine. It should be noted that the Colts, who were in third and long all night, converted 1 of 11 third downs.
Grade: F
RUN DEFENSE
The bad news is, the Texans ran for 167 yards, 107 of those by running back David Montgomery. The good news is, some of the rookies on defense continue to flash. Indy’s five defensive rookies totaled 35 tackles, the most production they’ve gotten from defensive rookies since 2007. (I did not look that up.) Allen reminded me of the 2018 Washington game when Darius Leonard made his star turn and burst onto the scene with his bravura performance his rookie season. Allen had 16 tackles, like Hunter Wohler last week, including seven solo tackles and one tackle for loss. That’s the rookie’s third double-digit tackle game, the first time that’s happened since Leonard burst onto the scene in 2018. Finally, we’re seeing what Chris Ballard and the scouts saw when they drafted the Georgia player in the second round. Meanwhile, Haulcy had an interception, nine tackles and one pass defensed. Crazy thing, this might turn out to be one of Ballard’s best top-to-bottom drafts, which is both sad and ironic. But hopeful.
Grade: C-
PASS OFFENSE
When Steichen says, “We’re evaluating everything”, as he said after Thursday night’s desultory 26-3 loss to the Houston Texans, you know something is afoot. Steichen may be stubborn and fully enamored with Jones after his 10-game stretch last season, but in the end, he’s not an imbecile. Against Houston, Jones completed 12-of-27 passes for 144 yards (87 of them in the first quarter) and an interception. In a divided country, there’s one thing almost all of us could agree on: Anthony Richardson, who’s kept his head down and worked — and smoked some weed in his car (oops) — deserves one final opportunity to show what he’s about. Can he do better than Jones? Better to ask this question: How can he do worse? I understand, the quarterback is operating with a barebones receiving corps and a re-shuffled offensive line, and Jones had Houston’s C.J. Anderson attached to his sternum all evening, but at this point, what have you got to lose except more games?
Grade: F
PASS DEFENSE
Once again, the explosive plays killed the Colts. (What exactly is the difference between an explosive and a chunk play? Please advise) Colt-killer Nico Collins only had three catches for 56 yards, but one of them was a 42-yard touchdown. On rare occasions, Lou Anarumo played man to man and left his thin secondary on an island, and he paid for it. Then there was a 24-yard TD pass to Kayshon Boutte. Most of the game, the Colts DC played in a two-high-safeties shell, forcing the Texans to dink and dunk their way down the field. Which they did. Until the two explosive/chunk plays, the eighth and ninth 20+ yard TD catches the Colts have surrendered this season, most in the league. Haulcy has his first NFL interception, the ball bouncing off his helmet, ricocheting off Cam Bynum and landing gently in Haulcy’s awaiting arms. Another strong game from AFC Defensive Player of the Week, Justin Walley, who finished with five tackles and one tackle for loss. All in all, it was a representative performance, a bright spot considering Charvarius Ward and Sauce Gardner were both out with injuries. Stroud has been playing at a Pro Bowl level this season; the Colts largely kept him under wraps.
Grade: B-
SPECIAL TEAMS
Count me as a big-time Seth McGowan fan. It’s not only his work at running back, but in the return game, he’s been outstanding. He returned three kickoffs Thursday for 117 yards, a 39-yard average. He now has nine kickoff returns of 30 yards or more. On the flip side, the normally perfect Spencer Shrader went 1-for-3, including a blocked attempt on a nonsensical 62-yard attempt in the first half.
Grade: B-
COACHING
On the pre-game show – or maybe it was halftime; who remembers? – Prime analyst Andrew Whitworth concluded that Steichen should return to the Colts sideline for next season. Now, I don’t know if he’s got Carlie Irsay-Gordon on speed dial, but I’m telling you this right now: The new general manager is going to want his own guy. An assistant or two might survive – doubtful, but it could happen – but Steichen is a goner. There’s no way the Colts can sell this team, can sell tickets, to a group coached by Steichen. Look, I understand he’s now operating with one hand tied behind his back, but he had his opportunities with a full deck and never produced. Said this before, I’ll say this again: Some offensive coordinators are better as OC’s than head coaches. In all the time Steichen has been here, I’ve never sensed that there’s any real direction, any discernable established culture established. Time for a change at season’s end.
Grade: D
INTANGIBLES
It boggles my mind to think about where the Colts were just one year ago around this time: They were sitting at 8-2, ranking first in points scored, third in passing yards, third in rushing yards and first in total yards. Then Jones tore his Achilles and it all went straight to hell. I don’t blame Ballard for committing to Jones this offseason. There was reason to believe Jones had turned a corner in his career. And anyway, who were the quarterback alternatives? Want to see Jacoby Brissett or Gardner Minshew again? And it’s just a two-year contract, which protected the team to some degree. I was willing to give Jones eight, nine games of grace since he was coming off the Achilles surgery, but now after 11 games, he’d regressed. Dramatically. Now America, forced to watch the Colts on national TV last night, knows our pain.




Good article. IMO, at this point, continuing to start Jones is coaching negligence. The season's lost, and so the real question is whether Richardson has a future here...and every game Jones starts is another wasted chance to find out. Even if Richardson fails that's still valuable information.
As a ticket season holder it is just dispiriting and mentally tiring. I am sorry you have to watch all of this trash. I blissful turned it off at half time. No reason to watch this movie. I knew the ending.