A quick note:
My apologies for failing to write the last couple of days. The flu kicked my butt and put me on the shelf for a couple of days. Anyway…here’s the Dopey Report Card off the Colts-Dolphins classic:
RUN OFFENSE
OK, so this season hasn’t been a complete disaster. I say that because a number of the younger players have started to develop, including seventh-round draft pick Seth McGowan at running back. Jonathan Taylor and McGowan combined for 160 yards on 28 carries (Taylor 83, McGowan 77), McGowan again showing that if the Colts move Taylor this spring, they have a decent replacement on the current roster. The last time the Colts had two runners go over 75 yards each was when Marlon Mack and Jordan Wilkins did it in 2019. More impressive, the Colts run game produced with a rebuilt offensive line that got even thinner when Bernhard Raimann went out with a concussion. But, then, they were playing the Dolphins, so everything comes with an asterisk.
Grade: B+
RUN DEFENSE
The Colts are getting some nice play from rookie linebacker CJ Allen, who couldn’t find the field earlier this season but is now playing exceedingly well since he received the green dot. He had a team-high nine tackles, two tackles for loss, one sack and one pass defensed. Earlier this year, we consistently asked defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo why Allen, a second-rounder who was supposed to be a green-dot from Day One, wasn’t seeing the field. He kept insisting it was just a matter of time, noting that Allen fell behind because of training-camp injuries. Turns out, Anarumo had it right. Allen has been one of the Colts’ few bright spots in recent weeks. The Dolphins ran for 78 yards on 26 carries, a 3-yard-per-carry average.
Grade: B
PASS OFFENSE
Good heavens. How poorly does Daniel Jones have to play before Shane Steichen comes to the conclusion that playing Anthony Richardson can’t possibly be any worse than what the Colts are currently getting from their starting quarterback? Yes, I can understand that Steichen wants to stick with Jones for this Thursday’s anticipated blood-letting against the Texans’ defense; it’s a short week, after all. But if that game goes the way most of us expect it to go, Steichen needs to turn to Richardson down the stretch of this lost season. I mean, how could it be worse? Jones was 11-of-22 for 108 yards, one touchdown to Laquon Treadwell and two picks. His passer rating was 1.7 – 1.7! – the lowest mark of any quarterback this season. And he managed that number against a terrible Dolphins pass defense. Granted, Jones doesn’t have a ton of help, playing with a receiving corps that had 27 combined catches coming into the game, not to mention a beat-up offensive line that got thinner when Raimann went out with a concussion. But when you get badly out-played by Miami’s Kyle McCord, a rookie making his first start, it’s time to do something dramatic. Am I holding my breath that Steichen will turn to AR? No, I am not.
Grade: F
PASS DEFENSE
Who would have thought Grover Stewart would be the Colts’ best defender against the pass? He knocked down three passes at the line of scrimmage, the most by a defensive tackle in team history. Adetomiwa Adebawore continued to make an impact, recovering a fumble in the end zone for a touchdown. Justin Walley, another guy who struggled early, is really coming on, finishing Sunday’s game with five tackles, two tackles for loss, his first career strip-sack, two passes defensed and one forced fumble. On the flip side, both Charvarius Ward and Sauce Gardner were injured during the game and are unlikely to play Thursday in Houston. C.J. Stroud and Nico Collins must be licking their chops.
Grade: B
SPECIAL TEAMS
McGowan had a nice day on kick returns, averaging 30.5 yards per attempt, and Ashton Dulin averaged 25.7, but beyond that, not much to report. Spencer Shrader kicked another one from beyond 50 yards, but we’ve come to expect that.
Grade: B
COACHING
I’m still not sure I understand why Steichen eschewed a 61-yard field goal attempt early in the game and chose to go for it on fourth-and-five at the Miami 43. By now, we know that Shrader has the range. Instead, Jones threw the first of his two interceptions. As this season wears on (and on…and on…and on), I’d like to see Steichen lean into the running game more. Clearly, the Colts are hapless and hopeless when they attempt to throw. By now, their only chance to win is by grinding out games on the ground. Remember the old days of “Run the damn ball”? That’s where they have to turn now. Will it make a major difference? Probably not, but it’s better than watching Jones attempt to throw the football, where only bad things happen.
Grade: C
INTANGIBLES
There’s a reason the Colts and Dolphins came into this game with a combined record of 3-14. They’re awful. And let’s be honest: If Zane Gonzalez doesn’t miss three kicks, the Colts lose this football game. (As I’m writing this, Gonzalez is being released by the Dolphins). Here’s a great stat courtesy of ESPN Research: The Colts are the first team in the Super Bowl era (since 1966) to win despite being outgained, losing the turnover battle and committing 10 more penalties than their opponent (13 to 3). The Colts were awful. The Dolphins were worse. A true classic if you’re into high comedy.
Grade: C




If Jones is still starting after Thursday's game with a mini-break following, then something is truly amiss. Not sure ownership is on the up and up here. Also, I do not get why they do not have packages for AR on short yardage, goal-line or as tactic to motivate the offense. None of this makes any sense to me unless it involves $$.